The case of the buried underpants

I read the following Soil health assessment using buried cotton underpants… with amused but limited interest. To me, it was a lot less interesting than the headlines made it sound. For one, they could have literally used *any piece of cloth* and gotten similar result. Writing the word “underpants” in the headlines probably made both the experiment as well as the reporting of it more sensational than it was. There is nothing unique about one’s underwear that makes it more suited for this experiment.

And, the underwear in question was not even “one’s underwear”. They were bought in bulk by those conducting the experiment and mailed to “citizens” who then did the act of burying them, excavating them, logging the results and sending the results back. In that sense, the citizens were more of data-collectors rather than scientists. At the risk of sounding like a hair-splitting pedant, this mislabeling continues to remain my pet peeve about “citizen science” (note the double-quotes").

Soil, of course, is one of the most vital resources for our life as we know it, so anything that makes use not treat it like dirt is positive.

Note to self: consider acquiring organic cotton underwear for once

1 Like

Nice to hear! Yeah… we were following this “Soil your Undies” headline catching project years agoi, during our Humus Sapiens early phase.

It started in 2018, and it is kinda media hack, that worked! And we were quite dissappointed that “citizen science” had to go that path (only)… and the local Swiss people didnt come up with anything themselves, and just forked / copied / pirated the same media hype 3 years later. perfectly patched into the swiss medialandscape, slightly funny (but not too much), a little bit “dirty”, talking about underear (hihihihi)… its so boring.

our friends do much more interesting stuff with Soil Assembly:
https://soilassembly.net/

After years of local Swiss | Who owns “Citizen Science” | discussions. this is where we ended. the Big Universities copy projects from abroad and claim the territory.